Monday, October 26, 2009

A New Plan To Dump The Orthotics & Become Pain Free

In the time that I've been writing here I don't believe I've ever written a new article so soon after posting the previous one. Over the weekend I decided to drastically change (relatively speaking) my approach to getting out of my orthotics and free from Plantar Fasciitis (PF). And I've decided to turn this blog from a place that contains various ramblings about running and injuries into a chronicling of my new efforts to get out of all this shoe and orthotic hardware and really be pain free.

For many months the plan I've had with my podiatrist has been to use my current flexible orthotics to keep the PF in check, while allowing my feet to move and increase their strength. The goal has been to, ultimately, be orthotic free. I've been deeply committed to this philosophy as well as frustrated at the time it seems to be taking to make it happen. The doc has asked I be patient, that it will come with time, and he has said that I can continue to run on a limited basis. This has been going on for a year. On the one hand I'm running 3 miles every-other-day, which is light-years ahead of where I was 12 months ago. On the other hand I continue to deal with heel pain that comes and goes, which leads me to believe I'm not really getting better - totally better. In an effort to get over "that last little bit" I've been doing all sorts of things: hip strengthening, adjusting the degree of arch support, stretching, core strengthening, small amounts of barefoot running in grass, starting to change to a midfoot strike, etc. The bottom line is this: I'm not getting over "that last little bit" and I'm not able to determine if any given effort to make things better is really helping or not. Conversely, I'm not really sure if my small amount of running is too much and, consequently, undoing any progress I might be making.

I've been doing a large amount of reading recently that has strongly influenced my decision to approach this differently:
  • The Pose Running Method. Pose is a running form that focuses on efficiency as well as minimizing the stress running typically places on the body - ultimately resulting in lower injury rates. Dr. Nicholas Romanov created this method quite a number of years ago. It has brought positive results to many. Check out http://www.posetech.com/
  • Born To Run by Christopher McDougall. Chris searches out the Mexican Tarahumara Indians who are legendary runners. He does this because he has been told by his doctors to stop running due to his age and a variety of foot issues. He learns how the Tarahumara are able to run at levels most runners deem unattainable. When Chris adopts some of their basic principles he not only is able to run pain free, but he completes a 50 mile ultramarathon. If you take nothing else from this or future postings read this book. It's fabulous.
My new project is going to consist of the following plan. Much of this comes from the Pose website. Other components I've added myself.
  • Stop running. These two words are what the majority of runners least want to hear, however I think I need to take that entire variable out of the equation in order to see if I can make progress on the foot pain and strength and not wonder if I'm undoing progress when I subject my feet to the pounding of running.
  • Do a small amount of walking/running barefoot in grass. Experiment carefully to be sure it's not causing damage.
  • Learn and practice the Pose drills. Right now I'm using the Pose website as well as YouTube to learn about them, their purpose, etc.
  • Wear a Pose-endorsed shoe. The Pose philosophy, when it comes to shoes, is that a very minimalist shoe should be used - to encourage the foot to feel the ground and fire the right foot muscles appropriately. The belief is that the modern padded running shoe prevents this from happening and actually encourages us to run incorrectly.
  • Consistently execute a core and hip strengthening program. I have an exercise ball and will be using it to work on core strength.
  • Consistently work a program for improving balance. I think the Bosu Ball is the ideal solution here - but I'm not willing to drop $100 for the privilege. I've purchased a balance "disc" ($20). I'm also going to be doing some work my PT has suggested.
  • As I get to the point I can consistently do the above with no foot/heel pain, begin some extremely short (Did I say "extremely"? 200m? 400m?) runs on hard surfaces using the Pose method. If well tolerated, increase at an extremely conservative rate.
The first step for my plan is to get a shoe that adheres to the Pose philosophy. This is likely to be the first of a number of odd-feeling steps in this project. I've always run in the high end motion control models (Asics MC-Plus, Brooks Beast, Saucony Grid-Stabil). I like Saucony shoes. I looked on eBay and found a Saucony Bullet for $50. Talk about a shoe that is the exact opposite of a motion control shoe! It should be very interesting to give them a go.

Next Step & Goal: Get the shoes and start doing the Pose drills while wearing them - and see if I can just do them consistently without aggravating the foot pain. I'm not going to attempt any running (besides a very limited amount of barefoot grass running) until I can be sure I can do the basic drills pain free.

I can commit to giving updates here on how things progress. Whether those updates end up being reports of success or failure remains to be seen.

Jim

Running is a privilege.

[Return to the current blog posting.]


10 comments:

  1. It sounds like you're approaching this logically, and from a well-reasoned decision. It's just a hunch, but I'm guessing that your break from regular running while maintaining your strengthening routine will help you make real progress on your PF.

    I pray it goes well for you.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Jim, you should really consider a pair of Vibram FiveFingers. (They're even Pose-approved.)

    Take a look at the following review of Born to Run and the Vibrams, and do yourself a favor.

    "I bought the FiveFingers. I wore them to garden. I wore them around the house. I wore them on a power walk. And then, I ran 5 miles on the trail in them. No pain. No pain anywhere. I hadn't had such a pain-free run in years.

    "It was a mind-boggling experience. Forty years of wearing running shoes and, in under an hour, I became absolutely convinced that I'd been heading in the wrong direction with my running shoes."

    http://www.lansingstatejournal.com/article/20090901/SPORTS05/909010336/1446/SPORTS05

    ReplyDelete
  3. FMR: Thanks for the thoughts. Who knows how this will unfold. As a friend of mine likes to say "Never predict an outcome with anything more specific than 'Watch this.'".

    Tuck: Interesting about the VFF. They're very intriguing to me. You may be right - I might end up there. My issue is, trying to make the mental leap from motion control to racing flat, is about all my brain can handle. Trying to make the leap to VFF/BF makes my head want to explode. Right now - and I'm not joking - if I walk on my hardwood floors for more than 2 hours in a day my feet hurt the next day. They are REALLY REALLY weak.

    Jim

    ReplyDelete
  4. Jim,
    I would be really interested in seeing how this works for you. I think the trick is to retrain your feet and stance and gait properly and taking your time to do that and letting the pain in the feet be the guide to better running habits.
    i think there are some neat quotes on this in that book you gave me - 'born to run'

    ReplyDelete
  5. I'm thinking of some similar things, too, as I struggle through a shin splint (finally going to see a specialist about it on Tuesday). I see in your last post you tried Chi Running but didn't care for it. I'm going to give it the good ol' college try (ordered the book at my local independent bookseller, just need to go get it) and I'm just wondering what about it didn't work for you? I'm a little confused about what the difference between the two techniques are.

    ReplyDelete
  6. First of all, in my totally amateurish opinion, it appears to me that Pose and Chi Running are extremely similar. I'm guessing there will be folks who are big proponents of one or the other and say I'm all wet - but they appear very similar to me.

    I read the Chi Running book. What I didn't care for is that, when I went out to do it, it felt like I was trying to rub-myhead-and-pat-my-stomach. As I recall the book laid everything out, then said "Go do it." It just seemed like a lot to keep all straight. When I've watched the Pose drills and tried them myself they give you a feel for the various limb positions. So when running is attempted, there is a sensation in your brain you're trying to replicate. Recognize - I have not successfully gone to Pose. Heck - I haven't even received the book yet. We'll see how it goes.

    ReplyDelete
  7. "First of all, in my totally amateurish opinion, it appears to me that Pose and Chi Running are extremely similar."

    In my totally amateurish opinion, I entirely agree! I thought it was different names for the same thing.

    Good luck with Pose method, I'm looking forward to reading your blog as you progress in your no-orthotics goal!

    ReplyDelete
  8. The foot weakness is a big problem. Fortunately once you realize that your feet are weak, and that your orthotics and motion-control shoes are making them weaker, you're 90% of the way towards a solution.

    The problem you'll find with going to a racing flat (versus going all the way to Vibrams or barefoot) is that the flats will still allow you to heel strike as you're walking on hard surfaces and running. This is one of the most harmful habits shoes encourage, and one of the most important ones to break, in my experience.

    But, you've got to take it one step at a time (pun intended). You don't want to overwhelm yourself and get an injury (achilles tendon is particularly susceptible as it stretches and strengthens, as are stress fractures in the feet as you start running and not landing on the heel.

    Most important is to listen to your body, and only do what your body will allow you to do without pain.

    Good luck!

    ReplyDelete
  9. http://mattfitzgerald.org/blog/?p=22

    Jim, I'm following your story here and on the Pose forum. I thought you might be interested in the above item. (I'm not Joe Sparks, by the way, but I've tried the EZRun belt and I think it's a big help.) I believe he also improved it recently.
    I'd also suggest that you can save a LOT of time and effort by finding a good Pose coach as soon as you can. The Pose forum and video analysis are better than nothing, but a few sessions with a coach is far more effective.

    ReplyDelete
  10. nice guide! thank you!/I love it ! Very creative ! That's actually really cool Thanks
    Orthotics

    ReplyDelete